One year of being a one car family

Life as a one car family | RISING*SHINING
Life as a one car family | RISING*SHINING
Life as a one car family | RISING*SHINING

#thebackseatboys

This weekend we celebrated one year of being a one car family! I can’t believe it’s been a year already. I’m happy to report that being a one car family, even in the suburbs of a sprawling metro area, is going really well and we have no plans to change our situation.

When we sold Chris’s truck and made our 2008 Prius our only car we were determined to try our best but were open to buying another car if needed. At the time we only had one child (and one car seat) to fit in the car. One year and another baby – and car seat – later and we are doing fine with one car. We’ve found that we love having one car and we’ve been surprised at how easy it is to have just one car (on most days).

We also haven’t run into space issues with the Prius. Both car seats fit well, Chris and I still have some leg room in the front seat and the trunk holds the groceries/luggage/Bob stroller or whatever else we need bring with us. If Chris or I were taller the front seat would certainly be less comfortable but for our 5’9″ and 5’8″ frames it’s just fine. And if we ever do need a larger car for a time, such as a long road trip, we could easily rent a bigger car.

There are definitely some factors that make it feasible for our family to get by with one car that might not work for other families. This includes Chris and I working in close proximity enough that we can carpool and having public transportation available a short distance from our house that can get us to work (even though we don’t get there very fast!). But this year has also made me think that many families could also live with one car if they chose to do so. 

We live in the suburbs of a sprawling metro area and for the first six years that we lived here we assumed that we had to have two cars. And that was even before we had kids! When we made the leap to being a one car family it was when we had one child with another on the way and needed to transport car seats and make stops at daycare. And we’ve found that we can pretty easily do this. We could definitely have been living with one car before this! (Oh the money we could have saved!) I say this not to make anyone feel shameful for having two cars but just to invite you to reflect on whether a need is really a want if you have any interest in ditching a car but are convinced that it would be impossible.

There are some sacrifices, for sure. When I take public transportation to work each Tuesday it takes me over an hour to get to work using the bus and light rail whereas if I drove I could arrive in 40 minutes. But I look at what I am gaining. I get to read or listen to podcasts the entire way, two of my favorite past times. I also find that taking public transportation shakes things up and gives me perspective. Seeing different sights and different people takes me out of my routine and I think that’s a good thing. I am also reminded that I have the luxury of choosing to take public transportation and that many people get by without a car at all each day. In addition, owning one car has saved us an estimated $3,500 over the past year – money that goes right into our savings.

There have been other benefits as well. Chris and I spend more time together now that we carpool three days a week. And this time is important more than ever since having two young boys at home. We’ve had some really important conversations about our family, our budget and our future on our way to and from work. It’s also easy to fit in a quick mini-date to grab coffee before work. Honestly I think our carpooling has helped us to stay connected during this time of raising young children, which can certainly strain a relationship.

We also think carefully about errands that we need to run, consolidate trips and often run them together. We end up driving fewer miles overall this way plus we spend that time together instead of going our separate ways to run errands. 

There have been a few times we have needed an extra car when Chris had an evening event and needed to be somewhere at the same time that the boys need to be picked up from daycare. For these times we’ve been fortunate to be able to borrow car from Chris’s parents who live nearby. But if we were not able to do this we could have rented a car and this expense would still pale in comparison to the money we have saved by not owning a second car.

If you would like to test drive the one car lifestyle it’s an easy experiment to do. Just commit to leaving one car parked for a certain amount of time, say a week, and see what happens. You might have to get creative or compromise but you might find it’s easier than you thought and that there are unexpected benefits! 

12 responses to “One year of being a one car family”

  1. Sarah Avatar

    I love that you did this and are making it work. One of my favorite parts of getting rid of our car was removing the decision making. I didn’t have to decide if I was taking the car or not; I just found another way. Sometimes we have to rent a car, but as you said, it is so.much.cheaper. to do it that way. Congrats to the Whartons on their first year as a one-car family!

    1. Kelsey Avatar

      Yes, I hadnt thought of it that way but you are right. You guys are an inspiration!

  2. Kristy Avatar

    Hooray for the Whartons! Love hearing about your experience over the year as a one car family. So happy it is working out well for you guys! We’ve thought about going down to one car but just can’t figure out how to make it work logistically for our family right now so we’re happily a two small car suburban family with 3 kids which is also rare! We jokingly refer to our Prius as “the van”. We’ve talked about renting a larger vehicle too if need be but haven’t had any problems fitting everything and everyone (including boosters and car seats) in for long trips or loading up the car with all our bikes and bike trailer to go somewhere to ride. I think the grocery space in the back is pretty near equivalent, if not better because it has more depth, to a van or SUV. Even at 6′ my husband doesn’t feel cramped.

    1. Kelsey Avatar

      3 kids in a Prius, I’m impressed! Awesome to hear that it’s still serving you well. I do think the trunk space is pretty impressive!

  3. Catherine Short Avatar

    Way to go! My husband and I were a one car family for the first 2 1/2 years of our marriage. We were beginning to discuss if we could go back to being a one car family right at the point that we decided to move. I could see us going back at some point, but we own our cars now and since we don’t live near family it is nice having that second car!

    1. Kelsey Avatar

      Nice! And it’ll be easy to try out having one car if you ever what to by leaving a car parked, you could even remove insurance from it to save that money to test out not using it without actually getting rid of it.

  4. Kathleen Avatar

    I love this. We have a Prius with 2 kids also, but right now my husband has a truck (with only room for one car seat). They are both paid off, but if the truck breaks down I hope I can convince him not to get a new car!

    1. Kelsey Avatar

      Thats so similar to our situation! A paid off car is great to have around if the maintenance isnt too much. Good luck on making it go as a one car family if you decide to try it eventually!

  5. Natanya Avatar

    Congrats on making it one year! My husband and I went down to one car in February and it’s been great! It helps that we live 7 minutes from either of our workplaces so its easy for me to drop him off before I need to go to the office or run errands. And the time together in the car in the morning and at the end of the day is special too. (even if it is only 5-10 minutes). Like you said, there are sacrifices, but we think it’s been worth it!

    1. Kelsey Avatar

      Oh my goodness, being 7 minutes from work sounds so amazing! Carpool time is so nice, especially when you have small children. Love hearing from other one car families!

  6. Kelley Avatar

    One car isn’t working. I find more negative. My guess is you don’t have a disability or any driving anxiety. Maybe you know the area you live in well. All I can say is when you’re new in town and no family or friends nearby. When your husband doesn’t share the car. It’s not easy with small children you must take everywhere with you. I find it very difficult and we have been a one family car for 6 years now. It is harder not easier each year. I frequently have to cancel activities or appointments last minute. Not near any public transportation, do not have a double stroller and heavy traffic on the main roads near my house. Oldest doesn’t mind me well about traffic. So walking is out. Not that the places we would need to be are in walking distance.

    1. Kelsey Avatar

      Hi Kelley, thank you for sharing your perspective. Being a one car family is something that we’ve found works really well for us but I definitely agree with you that it is not something everyone is able to do or would want to do depending on circumstances. I’m so sorry you are facing these challenges being a one car family and the obstacles you mention do sound really frustrating.

Leave a Reply