On Being Vegetarian

Today I'm happy to share a guest post from Chris! Since he's a nutrition professor by day I asked him to write about some of the nutritional aspects of our "being vegan" experiment, which we're trying out this week.

Rwedding-buffet

We served veggie burgers at our wedding!

Professors are a strange breed. Regardless of discipline, we all are rife with idiosyncrasies and social maladaptation we think can somehow be forgiven because we’re introspective nerd-geniuses. The truth is, although many of us are introspective and nerdy, very few of us are geniuses. I fallinto this camp: I’m just extra-eccentric without the brilliant mind to match.

Part of my eccentricity, however, lies in the fact that I like to experiment with stuff. I study food and health in my day job, and that’s as much fun to learn about academically as it is to play with personally. So, I end up running little dietary experiments in my own life to see what I think and feel.

Good thing is, I don’t try anything too extreme when it comes to our home diet (unlike my bachelor years when I would eat a pound of broccoli a day in the name of science, or down multiple energy drinks just to see how it’d feel). These days, I’m on to something new, and it’s something Kels and I thought would be fun to try: veganism.

Extreme though it may sound, it’s really not; as a speaker we saw last week said, “Do you like PB & J? Then you like vegan food.” Kelsey and I have been qualified vegetarians for a while (‘qualified’ because we eat eggs, fish, and dairy). So we weren’t far off from veganism to begin with. All we really had to do was replace the dairy and stop eating the minimal fish and eggs we were before.

To see what stood between us and veganism we went through the pantry and fridge, and took stock of all non-vegan foods. For us, there were 10 items, such as eggs, milk, yogurt, and Trader Joe’s veggie burgers (contains egg…dang! They are so delicious!), but most were easy to nix or substitute.

This past weekend, we made a vegan plan and began trying it out. Kels already makes amazing bean-, lentil-, or quinoa-based meals, so dinner’s covered. We bought more fruits and greens than normal for the week, and we’re giving some non-dairy milks a try (soy and almond to start). All that coupled with buying a few types of whole-grain breads (one loaf and one pack of tortillas) rounds out our other meals.

There are some definite benefits and detriments to this experiment. Benefits are easy: in two days’ time, our fruit/veggie/fiber intake has skyrocketed without trying too hard (not to mention lessening animal ethics concerns and some impacts on the environment). Detriments come in the form of some nutrients that are hard to get from plant foods alone. Primary among them are vitamins D and B12; zinc, calcium, and iron; and omega-3 fatty acids.

We live in Arizona, so vitamin D is a bit less of an issue. If you live in northern latitudes, it can be more of a problem…especially if you have darker skin. If anyone out there wanted to try veganism, vitamin D is a nutrient I’d recommend supplementing. I’d make the same recommendation for B12. B12 is a vitamin that naturally is found in lots of animal products, but almost not at all in plant foods. Iron and zinc are less difficult to get from plant foods, but still harder than getting from animal products. Same goes for calcium and omega-3s.

Much of this is easily handled though. Kels and I like ready-to-eat cereal, and lots of cereals are fortified with most of these nutrients. The ones we buy have all of the above, even the omega-3s if flaxseed is one of the ingredients. So, I have a pretty straightforward strategy that doesn’t require us thinking too hard: fortified cereals + regular vegan diet + occasional multivitamin, and we should be all good. (Use canola oil in your baking and you’ll up your omega-3s even more.)

One other aspect is key: variety. Everybody needs “complete protein” in their diets. That means, across the day, we need to eat foods that contain all essential amino acids that make up a complete protein. Animal-based foods have a complete set of amino acids, but most plant-based foods don’t (with the exception of soy products and quinoa).

So, if you try to eat a vegan diet, mix in soy and quinoa when possible, and otherwise create meals with combinations of your more protein-y, fibrous foods (for instance, couple legumes with whole grains, have some nuts here and there, and mix up your veggies). Add variety, and you’ll be fine.

Thanks, Chris! If there are any nutrition-related questions about eating a vegetarian or vegan diet, or nutrition questions in general, please ask away in the comments; this guy is a wealth of knowledge.

7 responses to “On Being Vegetarian”

  1. Sara Avatar

    Hi Chris and Kelsey!

    I’ve been a vegetarian for about 11 years. Just last night, someone asked me why. I explained that I do not support the way the mainstream meat industry treats animals or injects dubious hormones. I also explained that meat production is bad for the environment. Is that actually true? I realized that all of my sources are pretty biased. If it is true, do you have a link to an unbiased article that I could share? He was arguing that he had never seen a side-by-side comparison of the environmental impact of raising meat versus vegetables.

    Also, will you explain why you’re a pescetarian? And why don’t you use the word pescetarian?

    Thanks! Loved this article as well as the one about ties. Please move to Austin so we can all be friends. We’ll dress up like board game characters with you any time!

    1. Chris Avatar

      Hey Sara,
      Thanks for the comments! It’s definitely true that meat production is bad for the environment for all sorts of reasons. I could cite you dozens of studies, but I think the graphic in this NY Times article is a nice, definitive chart to drive the point home…and it fits the bill of comparing different ag products side-by-side on the same measure. If you click the Multimedia pic on the left, you’ll see the chart I’m talking about. It’s a reproduction of data from a UN report on livestock. On the left, you’ll see data on meat production and consumption in developing countries, showing that demand and consumption are rising in the most populous countries in the world. On the right, you see a comparison of lbs of CO2 produced for every lb of food product produced. Red meat, and animal products in general, are the worst offenders. Put high demand and high CO2 production together, and you can see producing meat is a much bigger problem than, say, producing oats.

      Regarding the term ‘pescatarian,’ I don’t often use the word only because I think it can be a little confusing. A pescatarian can be a vegetarian who eats fish but no other animal products, or a person who eats fish + eggs + dairy, or some combination. So, just to concise, I usually just say we’re vegetarian even though that’s a slightly incorrect approximation of the term.

      We were pescatarian primarily for nutrition and environmental reasons. Vegetarianism + fish is a pretty sound diet (think the Mediterranean diet or this dietary plan). And, if you pick your fish from well-managed fisheries, your environmental impact isn’t bad. But, more and more these days, I have trouble discounting issues of animal ethics, which is why we’re giving veganism a go.

      Thanks so much for reading these guest posts. I don’t blog often so I appreciate the feedback! And we might not be moving to Austin any time soon, but we definitely visit a lot! SXSW is calling!

    2. Sara Avatar

      Thanks for your thorough response, Chris!

      One more question: When/if you have children, do you plan to raise them as vegetarians, too?

    3. Chris Avatar

      Good question, Sara. I haven’t researched it thoroughly enough as of yet, but I’d say we’re likely to raise our kids on the same ‘qualified’ vegetarian diet we were following (lacto-ovo-pescatarian). Although I’m no longer much of a fan of dairy in general, Organic Valley is a dairy I trust and respect because I’ve met a number of those farmers (they’re expensive but worth it). It’s also easy enough these days to source eggs from responsibly and ethically managed farms, and to find fish in the stores that come from well-managed fisheries.

      I have yet to think about what happens at family gatherings or friends’ houses or school. Oy.

      Are you raising your son vegetarian?

  2. Melissa Blake Avatar

    oh, that’s really interesting!

  3. Moxie Avatar

    From what I’ve read & understand, meat & seafood production/consumption is bad for the environment for several reasons, including:
    1) pollution of air via methane emissions–worse than CO2, in terms of contributing to global warming,
    2) pollution of waterways, by animal waste,
    3) damage to fragile eco-systems [particularly the way many sea creatures are fished/harvested–near extinction of several species commonly eaten by humans. Read more: http://blogs.houstonpress.com/eating/2011/09/10_fish_youre_eating_that_are.php%5D,
    4) destruction of forests & open spaces for grazing land–major loss of topsoil, habitats for wild animals, sea sanctuaries & coral reefs,
    5) negative impact on human health via factory farming usage of unnecessary/unstudied/and/or/overused hormones & medication, with unknown side effects & consequences to human health, as well as via direct transmission of animal diseases to humans [a la “mad cow” disease/BSE, poultry & swine flu].

    If you consider the UN an unbiased source, they have several reports related to meat production over the years, and at one point were quoted as saying the following in UK’s Guardian newspaper:

    The UN’s Food and Agriculture Organisation has estimated that meat production accounts for nearly a fifth of global greenhouse gas emissions. These are generated during the production of animal feeds, for example, while ruminants, particularly cows, emit methane, which is 23 times more effective as a global warming agent than carbon dioxide.
    The full report is available here: http://www.fao.org/docrep/010/a0701e/a0701e00.HTM

    Here’s a short answer to your friend’s question about looking for a direct comparison about the impact of raising meat vs. plant-based food from Scientific American:

    Pound for pound, beef production generates greenhouse gases that contribute more than 13 times as much to global warming as do the gases emitted from producing chicken.
    For [comparison of beef production to production of] potatoes, the multiplier is 57.
    … Producing the annual beef diet of the average American emits as much greenhouse gas as a car driven more than 1,800 miles.

    This link has easy-to-read visual aids: http://www.scientificamerican.com/slideshow.cfm?id=the-greenhouse-hamburger
    Sorry this is a little long! I’ve been wanting to look up these things for myself for a while, but your question helped me actually get started! When I get around to putting together something more concise & easier to read, I’ll let you know!

    1. Kelsey Avatar

      Thanks so much for all this great information Moxie, these are great resources! If you end up doing a blog post on this topic I’d love to know!

Leave a Reply